Reservation is always a hot topic for media and politicians and always a big head ache for the system. No Politician ever want to loose votes from the minorities and hence they never speaks a word against Reservation.
I was always left
wondering why do we have reservation. its merits, its demerits, its implementation etc..
Let us analyze it in a broader view.
We have a bigger society were some are really privileged with all the facilities of life and some cant even dream of those facilities. To make the country progress in a proper way we need progress of all class of the society both privileged and under privileged. we cant expect the second section of people(the underprivileged) to shine in every field as the first section (the privileged). Here we need to keep some Reservation so that we can ensure a minimum number of people from the under privileged section also gets chance to access the knowledge and other resources that they otherwise wont get.
So Now How to Implement it ? many have different views. But i got mine. It is focused on particular Scenario i thought about. It might not hold true for all situations.
Let us assume we have admission to 100 seats in a college . out of which 25% is reserved for particular section (say section 1)of people and another 25% reserved for another section of people (say section 2). Rest 50% goes as General
Assume In the rank list in top 50 ranks we have 12 people from section 1 and 15 people from section 2 and rest 23 from the general category. and between ranks 51 and 80 we have 10 people from section 1 and 15 people from section 2 and between ranks 81 to 100 we have 20 people from general section. and between ranks 101 and 150 we have 4 people from section 1 and 5 people from section 2 and 41 people from general section and above 150 there are lots of people from all these sections
Now how should we assign the seats. ?
Let us check out the Normal procedure in practice
Normally what happens is that irrespective of reservation top 50 will get into the 50 general seats available. and in the rest 50 reserved seats the section 1 and section 2 people gets in over taking the merit of the general category people and this will always result in a situation like (in this particular scenario) we have 37 people of section 1 and 40 people of section 2 gets seats and only 23 people from general section gets seats in general category. It surely gives priority to the under privileged sections through reservations but also to a huge extend this procedure denies the chance of the eligible people who better deserve the seats. like The people of general section who got ranks between 51 and 100 gets don’t get a chance of admission where as people of section 1 and 2 and have ranks above 100 still have gets a seat.
I believe this actually results in the negative equilibrium of what the reservation actually is intended for.
So how should we go about filling the reservation seats. ?
Assign the 12 people of section 1 and 15 people of section 2 into the respective reservation categories. that is after assigning seats for top 50 people the situation will be like
Reservation section 1 - 12/25
Reservation section 2 - 15/25
General - 23/50
Now assigning the next 50 ranks reservation categories goes into reservation tables. and when reservation seats are over they gets chance for general seats if available
Reservation section 1 - 22/25
Reservation section 2 - 25/25
General - 50/50 (5 people of section 2 also gets seat in general section )
and also 3 people from section 1 whose ranks are above 100 gets their chance of admission in the reserved seats and 3 people of general category loses their chance
Which means we will have 25 people from section 1 and 30 people from section 2 and 45 from the general section getting admission. I feel Filling the seats in this pattern will promise a better distribution of seats.
I might be right I might be wrong. Feel Free to point out errors (i’m sure there are many) ..
Do keep in mind it is a particular scenario centric view.
I Believe we should reduce the percentage of reservation seats every 5 years and gradually eradicate the curse of reservation from our country. The politicians and religious leaders are the actual traffic blocks for this. Screw them